Alison Is Back, On Eighteenth
Wednesday, May 16, 2012 at 07:01PM 
A menu that is “casual” yet “refined;” décor details that are “sophisticated” yet “playful;” a restaurant that is both “simple” and “elegant.” These are just some of the oxymoronic descriptions used by Alison Price Becker and the team behind her latest restaurant, Alison Eighteen (on 18th Street), to describe what marks her first return to the Manhattan dining scene after a nine-year hiatus (her last New York venture was the beloved ’90s hit Alison on Dominick). The restaurant is nestled smack in the heart of the Flatiron District, an area of town we’re tempted to say—it can’t be resisted—is neither uptown nor downtown.
Maybe it is these rather contradictory juxtapositions at Alison Eighteen that make us ask if the restaurant is this or that, fish or foul, fancy or footloose? None of which is a bad thing, since the question begs for multiple return trips.
All ambiguities aside, one thing is for sure: executive chef Robert Gurvich knows good food. This being a semi-homage to the French brasserie, herb steamed mussels and sautéed foie gras occupy a rightful place at the front of the menu, but the grilled Portuguese octopus and the polenta with foraged mushrooms are so exceptional that your taste buds won’t know what hit them (you’ll have to ask the waiter yourself how they strip the octopus of any rubber-like consistency). The rotisserie delivers formidable spit-roasted chicken and lamb shoulder (no-questions-asked winners), but the poached halibut with fennel marmalade capers, blood oranges, and pistachios flakes onto your fork like little divots of divinity. And where else besides France will you find chestnut crème (an acquired taste, perhaps) with caramelized apples, chantilly, and meringue sticks?
Price Becker teamed up with Asfour Guzy Architects to create a relaxed, open, and timeless space inspired by the classic brasseries of Paris. And so there are eggplant-colored tufted banquettes, light terrazzo floors, warm walnut tables, and bronze sconces and chandeliers everywhere. The French inspiration carries through in the toile wallpaper, though this isn’t Bunny’s toile; instead, a custom print presents caricatured animals, New York scenes, and Alison herself. The effect is to stir up a seemingly relaxed space. Still, as a recent review noted, men aren’t obliged to wear blazers, but most of the clientele seems to come with a self-imposed, semi-formal dress code. And the friendly brasserie-like waiter service can be punctuated by overly attentive water pourers scared to let a glass dip below the “half empty” mark—thereby constantly interrupting gossipy tables from figuring out if the couple sitting across from them is a business man with his mistress or merely a regular with his art dealer who hasn’t gotten the memo that even Debbie Harry wouldn’t try pulling off the Blondie look after a certain age.
With a solid menu at stake, though, maybe it doesn’t matter what mix of dress-up, dress-down Alison is going for here.























